Can a commercial airliner sink to the bottom of the ocean?

gerrit
  • Can a commercial airliner sink to the bottom of the ocean? gerrit

    Is it possible that a commercial airliner could hit the ocean surface at such an angle that it made a deep dive intact, got filled with water, sank, and got stuck in mud at the floor of the ocean?

  • Hitting water at speed is a lot like hitting concrete (try experimenting with different positions hitting the water off a high diving board—some will hurt). Aircraft are simply not designed to withstand the sudden forces introduced upon impact with water, no matter the angle. If an aircraft were to hit the water at high speed, the relatively flimsy structures of the aircraft would shatter, disintegrate, and completely lose structural integrity.

  • Can a large modern jet airliner plunge intact underwater from flight?

    No.

    Large airliners are not desgned for this and are not even strong enough to make a landing on water in less than perfect conditions.

    enter image description here
    E.g. 961

    striking the surface at a larger angle would certainly lead to widespread disintegration.

    Is it possible for a large modern jet airliner to sink intact?

    Yes (as near as makes no difference)

    Almost all large aircraft impacting the sea surface in an emergency or uncontrolled will break up immediately and catastrophically.

    One notable exception was US1549, an A320, which was landed on water without breaking up. It was described as "still virtually intact though partially submerged and slowly sinking". The left engine detached and sank.

    enter image description here

    So a controlled landing on water is possible under extremely favourable circumstances. It would then be possible for the aircraft to sink in more-or-less one piece without creating a large amount of floating debris.

  • If A320 can land on Hudson river without breaking up, then MH370 also can land on Indian ocean without breaking up.

  • If the plane flew to empty, and the pilot made a manual controlled glide and water landing, he would still strike the water at a speed in excess of 150 mph.

    The engines would still be ripped off, baggage hold doors would most likely open on impact. There would have to be some kind of debris field. The plane would sink, but not intact.

    Something would come free and float to the surface.

  • My answer is: It depends. As always.

    Generally, yes, it is possible to land an aircraft on water intact. But the aircraft has to help you with that. If the engines are not below the wings (turboprop, piston, jet at the rear fuselage), and the pilot flares to minimum speed right above the water, gear up, then most aircraft will stay intact. Many are even tested for ditching qualities during development. I personally know of the ditching tests of the Breguet Atlantique and the Antonov-70, and there are certainly more (see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jK8ydLY5QHQ at 2:15 min into the movie).

    A Dutch Atlantique once had to go down and landed intact in the North Sea. It was towed into a harbor and lifted out of the water a few days later. The openings (for cooling air etc) have special valves which close automatically when the aircraft is in the water, much like a snorkel on a submarine (sorry, could not find a web source for this).

  • It would be judged upon the state of the aircraft once stopped after the collision, taking into account velocity and angle of impact etc.

    If the A/C is in-tact and no water is taken on-board it will float for a greater time but I highly doubt it will for a large amount of time because water always finds entry points.

Related questions and answers
  • Is it possible that a commercial airliner could hit the ocean surface at such an angle that it made a deep dive intact, got filled with water, sank, and got stuck in mud at the floor of the ocean?

  • When the transponder on Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 went off, there was no ALARM. The satellite kept getting pings, and apparently "knew" that the transponder was off. Would it not be a great idea if the Malaysia Airlines got an alarm indication that the transponder was off on one of their planes? The airline could have radioed the pilot and asked what the trouble was. If the pilots did not respond, some jets could have been scrambled to checkout what is going on. The scrambled jets could have followed the airliner for hours and watched them crash in the ocean, when they ran out of fuel. We

  • As a private pilot, I am familiar with tower, ground, approach and departure, but I am aware that there are other entities like clearance, pushback and center. If I were flying a commercial airliner, what is a complete, ordered list of entities (and a brief description of roles) I might talk with over a flight between two class B airports?

  • Commercial Jets tires Arjun Khosla

    I imagine that the tires on commercial jets wear out pretty fast with all those squealing landings as the tire suddenly has to spin up from zero to the speed of landing. 2 questions: How many landings does any average commercial airliner tire last before it is discarded? Before landing, why not have a small motor assembly on the landing gear to spin up the tires to the correct speed? Surely this would avoid the degrading tire burn. The tire might last a lot longer and might even offset the cost of the motor assembly.

  • On a commercial airliner, there is a hole in one of the layer of the passenger windows. See here: and here: Or in more detail: Can you explain the physical reasons for this design choice?

  • So every once in awhile I see an article talking about the air traffic control strikes in Europe like this one: European air traffic controllers to strike. How does this affect me if I am flying to Europe? Do they just close the doors and all airspace becomes uncontrolled airspace? I'm guessing not, but that's what I envision when I hear that! What happens if they go on strike while I'm over the ocean on my way there?

  • that radio beacon. We have not yet picked up anything, but that's typically what those black boxes contain." I was under the (potentially incorrect) impression that flight recorders, by nature of the materials needed to protect their contents in the event of a crash, are quite dense and unable to float in water. I base this impression on news reporting of other airliner crashes (such as Air France 447, which crashed in the Atlantic), where the recorders were found some time later on the ocean floor. Additionally, it seems reasonable to me that one would want to have the recorders not float so

  • In Rickenbacher's autobiography he tells of his flight across the Atlantic in a B-17 after WWII. They ended up running out of gas as I recall, making a water landing in the middle of the ocean. They were stranded for about a month before being rescued. In the early post-WWII era, how was it that they were able to find him at all? What factors contributed?

  • I understand that a large(r) commercial jet slows down after landing using the following methods: Wheel brakes Reverse thrust Spoilers/flaps/airbrakes What is the effectiveness of each compared to the others? What if one of the first 2 fails? Can an airliner usually be stopped without using wheel brakes or without using reverse thrust? And what if the runway is slick because of rain, snow or ice? Does that change the equation?

  • According to Airbus: ‐ After the flight crew selects reverse thrust, they must perform a full stop landing. Does it really make sense to have this limitation, and why? What happens if you realise there's not enough space to land, and you've still got adequate speed?